Front PageBusinessArtsCarsLifestyleFamilyTravelSportsSciTechNatureFiction
Search  
search
date/time
Sun, 9:00PM
light rain
5.9°C
W 17mph
Sunrise6:26AM
Sunset6:13PM
Artis-Ann
Features Writer
P.ublished 14th March 2026
arts

Choices Are Never Easy: Birnam Wood By Eleanor Catton

Obviously, the title of this novel would attract any self-respecting teacher (or student) of English Literature even though the blurb makes it quite clear that Shakespeare’s Scottish play has nothing to do with it – or has it?

As so often happens, the opening pages introduce the characters: Mira is the principal protagonist and de facto leader of the collective which is known as Birnam Wood and which is ‘on the move’ – ah, that may be the link to the Bard; her friend Shelley, who at the start has become somewhat disillusioned with the group, harbours deep-seated resentments against Mira and is plotting her escape. The wealthy Owen Darvish and his wife, soon to be Lady Darvish, have done very well from their pest control business, and, of course, there is Tony, a founding member of Birnam Wood, and aspiring journalist who is back from travelling and teaching English in Mexico. He has fond memories of his leaving party and his tryst with Mira, despite there having been no contact between them in the intervening four years. He has a secret (of course), namely vast inherited wealth which is belied by his carefully constructed appearance. When the billionaire Robert Lemoine enters the fray, his commanding presence cannot be ignored.

The tension builds gradually to an unexpected explosive and exciting ending, a truly bloody crescendo – yet another link to the Bard’s work, perhaps.
Catton spends a lot of time presenting the characters, their background stories and the interactions between them. It is hard going at first and the pace is initially slow but the detail is essential to an understanding of the motivations behind the behaviour of individual characters.

In brief, the novel is set in New Zealand. Mira is the founder of a collective gardening group, a group of idealistic twenty-somethings who plant their crops on neglected plots of land, not caring if they are trespassing or not. They are anti-capitalist with a strong anarchic streak and their idealism sees nothing wrong in using land which is being wasted and hoarded by wealthy people who don’t appear to care.

They struggle to get by, selling what produce they can, living frugally and investing any spare income in the collective, to buy tools, supplement seeds etc. When a deadly landslide leaves a particular piece of land isolated, Mira thinks their problems are over. The property is an abandoned farm located in the fictional town of Thorndike, by the Korowai pass, and is ripe for planting. However, Birnam Wood are not the only ones interested in the place. Robert Lemoine, an American drone-building billionaire, is looking for a site for his end of the world bunker and sees the possibilities. He has enough money to believe he can buy (and control) anyone and anything he wants and he is about to butt heads with others in the cast. Lemoine proposes to share the place but while his offer means they can grow and be secure, he represents everything their anti-capitalist group despises. Darvish wants Lemoine’s technology for his own purposes and courts him despite the danger. When a suspicious Tony realises Lemoine has a more sinister, hidden agenda, he decides to expose him – risky to say the least. Each character has their own reason for behaving as they do and it seems no-one is completely honest.

Lovers of crime novels will find plenty to enjoy but there are also plenty of philosophical discussions about controversial themes...
The narrative then enters a much faster-paced, more exciting phase. Lemoine is a bad man, capable of real evil, yet still people try to use him, choosing to ignore the danger – until it is too late. The tension builds gradually to an unexpected explosive and exciting ending, a truly bloody crescendo – yet another link to the Bard’s work, perhaps.

The novel is part social satire, part eco-thriller. Lovers of crime novels will find plenty to enjoy but there are also plenty of philosophical discussions about controversial themes such as collectivism, capitalism and climate change, delivered in exchanges between the characters, in several long speeches and one very long speech.

In fact, Catton takes her cues from Shakespeare’s play, focusing on the fatal flaws of individuals, the ambitions and personal desires which, like Macbeth, ultimately lead her cast to their downfall. 

On a purely personal note, I did find it a little off-putting that the narrative is not broken down into chapters; the whole novel is divided into three very long sections of pretty much equal length and I often found myself asking where I could stop reading and on picking it up again, where I should start? It’s better read in longer chunks in order to grasp more securely both the characters, their motivations and relationships, and the action.


Birnam Wood is published by Granta